The editors of This Old House magazine have put together a collection of the best old house neighbourhoods in the US, Canada, and Puerto Rico. Their criteria are architectural diversity, craftsmanship of the homes, preservation momentum in the neighbourhoods, and amenities such as walkability, safety, and community.
Here are their choices for the 12 best old house neigbourhoods in Canada. Traveling from west to east…
Dawson City | Yukon Territory
Over 100 homes in Dawson City were built during the Gold Rush days in the late 1800s. More than 60,000 tourists come to Dawson City each year, but the permanent population is only about 1,800.

Cranbrook, British Columbia
The Canadian Pacific Railway established a station in Cranbrook in 1898, and a city was born. Cranbrook’s period homes are concentrated in the historic Baker Hill neighbourhood.

Old Town | Yellowknife, Northwest Territories
Old Town was established in the 1940s when gold rushers headed to the mines in Yellowknife. They used local timber to build sturdy log cabins, which today can sell for around $600,000 (for cabins that have been renovated and modernized). At about 300 miles south of the Arctic Circle, winter temperatures can go down to the –40s F. So if you want to live in Old Town, you better like the cold!

London Road Neighbourhood | Lethbridge, Alberta
When Shell Oil announced that it was going to tear down a house in London Road in the 1980s and build a gas station in its place, a petition was circulated and enough signatures were acquired to nix those plans.

The Crescents | Regina, Saskatchewan
The Crescents was home to Regina’s wealthy during the early 20th century. House styles include Queen Anne, Craftsman, and Tudor.
West Broadway | Winnipeg, Manitoba
West Broadway dates back to the late 1800s when merchants and transportation magnates built fabulous home in this area. Less than a square mile in size, 5,200 residents currently call West Broadway home.

Leslieville | Toronto, Ontario
Once a gritty and industrial area, Leslieville now appeals to families, artists, and business owners who are attracted by its fashionable scene, safe streets, proximity to beaches, and affordable (relatively speaking!) housing.

Le Plateau Mont Royal | Montreal, Quebec
The Plateau is the “In” spot in Montreal right now. The duplexes and triplexes in The Plateau were built between 1880 and 1915 from local limestone, brick, or wood. Originally divided into multiple residences, many of them are now being converted into single-dwelling homes.

Saint Andrews, New Brunswick
British loyalists escaping persecution in the American colonies settled in Saint Andrews on the Bay of Fundy in 1783. Some of them actually dismantled their homes in the US, brought them to New Brunswick, and rebuilt them there. Local bylaws prohibit big box and chain stores, so the shops in town are the originals from the 1880s.

Charlottetown, Prince Edward Island
I can vouch for the fact that Charlottetown is a charming little city with equally charming homes. Did you know that Charlottetown is the birthplace of Canada? Yep, the second-largest country in the world was established in 1864 in our smallest province :-)

And for good measure, the beautiful B&B, Number One Grafton Street. (You can read my post about it here).

Central Halifax | Halifax, Nova Scotia
Some of the most enviable homes in Halifax are in the Central Halifax neighbourhood on the Halifax Peninsula. The colourful cedar-shingled townhouses were built in the late 1800s and are a five-minute walk from downtown Halifax.

St. John’s, Newfoundland
I haven’t been to Newfoundland yet, but Jelly Bean Row in St. John’s is my favourite Canadian neighbourhood. I would LOVE to live in one of these colourful row houses originally built around 1892. (You can read more about Jelly Bean Row over at DesignTies here and here).

If you live in one of these cities, I’d love to hear how you like it. And if there’s a city here that you’d like to learn more about, let me know and I’ll put together an in-depth post about it. Do you have a favourite city that you think should be on the list? Let me know, I’d love to check it out :-)
Shameless Plug Alert!
Just a few days left to vote for your favourite bedroom in the Bedroom Challenge in the HomeSense Shopper Showdown contest. If you like my bedroom, please vote for me! And if you don’t like it, vote for me anyway, OK? ;-)
If you want your home to reflect who you are and what you love, drop me a line for an in-person or online consultation.

All images from This Old House, with the exception of Number One Grafton Street.